Adam and Brett Graham were the ideal of what the perfect all American boys should be. Being paternal twins, they tended to gravitated toward one another and doing things together. High School was the high life for them, everything came naturally and easy, until they got to college. As time went on both men grew up and changed their way of thinking. Ready for more in life, they fight to overcome their past to be able to except their future.
Evangeline Hodgens grew up poor, and with no mom. She was stuck in a high school with the rich and idiotic, trying to make it through her day to day life. Evangeline accepts an opportunity after graduation that could bring her more than if she stayed in the town where the people gave her nothing but heartache.
But an accident brings Evangeline back to her small town right at the time she wanted to avoid most—her high school reunion. When she thought she could deal with the situation, she runs into the two men who terrorized her high school life and they don’t even seem to remember her. Evangeline soon finds herself in a predicament—risk a relationship with both men, keeping her new cover—or let the men see her for who she was—the Ugly Duckling of the town.